| August | |||||||
| Sat 24/8/1991 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 4-3 | | Liversedge | |
| Mon 26/8/1991 | NCELP | Ossett Town | | 1-1 | | Sutton Town | |
| Sat 31/8/1991 | NCELP | North Shields | | 1-0 | | Sutton Town | |
| September | |||||||
| Sat 7/9/1991 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 2-1 | | Thackley | |
| Sat 14/9/1991 | NCELP | Winterton Rangers | | 0-2 | | Sutton Town | |
| Wed 18/9/1991 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 1-0 | | Maltby Main | |
| Sat 21/9/1991 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 2-0 | | Glasshoughton Welfare | |
| Mon 23/9/1991 | NCELP | Sheffield | | 1-1 | | Sutton Town | |
| Sat 28/9/1991 | NCELP | Eccleshill United | | 1-3 | | Sutton Town | |
| October | |||||||
| Wed 2/10/1991 | PCP1L | Stocksbridge Park Steels | | 2-1 | | Sutton Town | |
| Sat 5/10/1991 | NCELP | Harrogate Railway | | 1-1 | | Sutton Town | |
| Sat 12/10/1991 | NSC1 | Arnold Town | | 1-3 | | Sutton Town | |
| Wed 16/10/1991 | PCP2L | Sutton Town | | 0-0 | | Stocksbridge Park Steels | |
| (Stocksbridge Park Steels won 2-1 on aggregate) | |||||||
| Sat 19/10/1991 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 5-1 | | Armthorpe Welfare | |
| November | |||||||
| Sat 2/11/1991 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 5-0 | | Eccleshill United | |
| Sat 9/11/1991 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 3-2 | | Harrogate Railway | |
| Sat 16/11/1991 | LC2 | Sutton Town | | 10-2 | | Brodsworth Welfare | |
| Sat 23/11/1991 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 2-1 | | Denaby United | |
| Sat 30/11/1991 | NCELP | Pontefract Collieries | | 1-4 | | Sutton Town | |
| December | |||||||
| Sat 7/12/1991 | NSC1 | Hucknall Town | | 2-1 | | Sutton Town | |
| Sat 28/12/1991 | NCELP | Armthorpe Welfare | | 1-0 | | Sutton Town | |
| January | |||||||
| Wed 1/1/1992 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 2-3 | | Belper Town | |
| Sat 4/1/1992 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 1-0 | | Brigg Town | |
| Sat 11/1/1992 | NCELP | Liversedge | | 0-6 | | Sutton Town | |
| Sat 18/1/1992 | LC3 | Spennymoor United | | 2-5 | | Sutton Town | |
| Sat 25/1/1992 | NCELP | Maltby Main | | 1-1 | | Sutton Town | |
| February | |||||||
| Sat 8/2/1992 | NCELP | Glasshoughton Welfare | | 2-2 | | Sutton Town | |
| Tue 18/2/1992 | NCELP | Belper Town | | 1-3 | | Sutton Town | |
| Sat 22/2/1992 | NCELP | Ossett Albion | | 3-1 | | Sutton Town | |
| Sat 29/2/1992 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 2-0 | | Ossett Albion | |
| March | |||||||
| Tue 3/3/1992 | LC4 | Sutton Town | | 2-1 | | North Ferriby United | |
| Sat 7/3/1992 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 2-0 | | North Ferriby United | |
| Sat 14/3/1992 | NCELP | Brigg Town | | 2-3 | | Sutton Town | |
| Sat 21/3/1992 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 1-3 | | North Shields | |
| Sat 28/3/1992 | NCELP | Spennymoor United | | 2-3 | | Sutton Town | |
| April | |||||||
| Wed 1/4/1992 | NCELP | Denaby United | | 2-2 | | Sutton Town | |
| Sat 4/4/1992 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 1-2 | | Spennymoor United | |
| Sat 11/4/1992 | LCSF | Sutton Town | | 0-3 | | North Shields | |
| Tue 14/4/1992 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 2-2 | | Ossett Town | |
| Sat 18/4/1992 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 4-1 | | Pontefract Collieries | |
| Mon 20/4/1992 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 4-0 | | Winterton Rangers | |
| Sat 25/4/1992 | NCELP | North Ferriby United | | 0-1 | | Sutton Town | |
| Tue 28/4/1992 | NCELP | Thackley | | 0-0 | | Sutton Town | |
| May | |||||||
| Sat 2/5/1992 | NCELP | Sutton Town | | 2-2 | | Sheffield | |